Smokin Fattys

The brisket mac and cheese was soooo good. We took Traveling Robert to dinner here. He's a YouTube celebrity who travels the country in a Winnebago. He enjoyed the brisket and an IPA.

I wanna start by saying we were there with a group, so I'm sure it wasn't easy!

Food was was hit or miss for us. Some of what we got was amazing, some was not good. My wife and I order all different items in order to taste more of what they offered (its just what we do). That is all a matter of preference not a hit at the recipe.

Wait staff was very generous with efforts to please and our waitress did a great job organizing orders and checks.

Here is my biggest complaint about the entire experience, the sweet tea was not sweet enough.

Finally, if management reads this I wanna know how to get my hands on some of the shirts the wait staff was wearing.

Didn't even add any sauce to the ribs. They were delicious!

The corn and potatoes were amazing!

Very very good. Now I understand why people are raving about Smokin Fattys. The pork belly is to die for. The baked beans and smoked cabbage are terrific. Can't wait to go back.

Best BBQ in Elkhart

Sat at bar, service was great. Food and drinks were alright nothing wrong with our food at all just not quite as flavorful as I would have liked. May have just been an off night willing to try again.

Absolutely loved it. Great beer choices and delicious food. We will definitely make this a regular date night stop.

Kari our server was very attentive. Food was good, large portions. Cheese curds were a great start, good size portion and delicious. I expected more quantity of the listed toppings on the salad I had, especially for the $15 price. For an entree meal it wasnt enough to satisfy my hunger. I also ordered the rib tip meal, which was huge! Corn and gigi cabbage were very well done, however rib tips were dry and way over seasoned. Too spicy for any of us and my husband wouldnt even eat the leftovers due to the spice. Would give it another try for sure, but wouldnt recommend a dinner salad or rib tips.

food and staff are everything you want in a good BBQ restaurant!!!

I'm so glad I stopped here. Amazing food!

Brooke is an amazing waitress, she has been the only waitress that has been serving me at every visit.

was amazing..food.our waitress.. I had the platter.all was delicious

Wow! Thank you for reminding me how restaurants are suppose to be! Most places I've been to lately are short staffed, there are long waiting times, stressed staff and food is overdone or served at room temperature. Your food is amazing, friendly staff, and no long waiting time. The blackberry bread pudding is great! Thank you Thank you! I'll be back, so many things I want to try!

Being a vegetarian, I still doing the Mac and cheese and elotes to be amazing! Highly recommend!

Had to wait 45 minutes to get a seat

Service was excellent and the food was absolutely amazing! Will be back soon.

Had a great time on our first visit. Can’t wait to go back!

Pulled pork was awesome and great in house beers! Will definitely be back

The ribs were so tender that they literally fell off of the bone. The pulled pork was also very tender. We loved all of the sides we tried and the service was excellent!

The ribs were so tender that they literally fell off the bone. The pulled pork was also very tender. Loved all the sides we tried and our server was amazing!

Good food sometimes it's a pain to have to wait . I should get there hours fixed food is good atmosphere is terrific

This is a great new place. The staff are very friendly and give great service. The sides are very good, but would love to see more low carb options. The BBQ sauces are fabulous. The first time e we had brisket was very juicy, the last two times the meat has been dry, this is my only complaint about the brisket. I’ll try another meat next time.

We had catering delivered this past Saturday. The whole experience was wonderful. The food was delivered on time and at perfect temperature. We easily could have fed double the amount of people! Very large portions and sent with tableware and serving utensils. Everyone loved it! We will do it again.