Cookie Mill

Debbie NAILED our order! We told her some colors we liked and the theme “Crayola” and she just made the cutest cookies! Little ink splatters, crayola boxes, and crayons with the kids names, along with paint your own cookies! Seriously so freaking cute and perfect :) AND they were soft and delicious cookies, not like the hard sugar cookies you get from the stores 😌 100% best party gifts ever

I’ve used the cookie milk several times and every time the cookies are amazing! You won’t find another company that pours into their work like the cookie mill! Love them!

I ordered custom sugar cookies from the Cookie Mill for my Mother’s 60th birthday celebrations, and let me tell you, they did not disappoint!!! My entire extended family surprised my mom in California at a vintage trailer park with the coolest vintage trainers. Debbie with the Cookie Mill went to their website (Hicksville Trailer Palace) and made cookie cutters of the exact trailers that we would all be staying in. They were absolutely adorable and tasted amazing. I’d order cookies from her again in a heart beat if I ever need a super cute and delicious themed dessert for any occasion. They were a huge hit with all the family. Thank you Debbie! You’re so talented at what you do :)

PERFECT! All I had to do was give her the colors and tell her the occasion! And a few hints of what the "mommy to be would like" and presto! The cookies I ordered were amazing. Debbie the owner and artist takes her job seriously and from her heart!! I ordered four dozen for small baby shower so that parents to be would be able to take some home with them . These are good size cookies making sharing easy also. These are professionally made cookies ,wrapped individually to keep them clean while guest had to admire the art. For our coed shower with kids , we also had other treats for tiny hands and appetites so cookies wouldn't become "party trash" on the kid tables.
Not only are they pretty but they tasted amazing.
I've known sugar cookies to be dry and dull.
Debbie's home made scratch baked cookies taste like they just came out of the oven ....

wow best tasting cookies i ever had!!

This is the second time we got cookies from Cookie Mill. Debbie is just incredible and the cookies taste just as amazing as they look!

I can’t say enough great things about the Cookie Mill, every order I’ve placed has EXCEEDED my expectations! Literally incredible!!!

Wow, wow, wow! These cookies were gorgeous, and delicious too. Thank you for making them so special and unique for my 60th…

I have ordered a few times from the Cookie Mill every time I am amazed at her work. I would totally recommend Cookie Mill for your cookies! Totally worth every penny spent!

I was so happy, these cookies turned out much better than I had imagined. Thank you @cookiemill